Economist’s Corner: The Role of Capital in Economic Outcomes for People of Color in New Jersey
By Richard Kasmin, NJEDA Chief Economist
Differential access to capital has impacted inequality throughout history. This issue of the Economist’s Corner examines how access to capital has affected people of color in New Jersey in the past and what we can do to address persistent inequalities moving forward.
In economics, capital refers to assets that can generate economic benefits. Generally, the first thing that comes to mind is physical capital, or fixed assets such as machines, computers, and structures such as offices and manufacturing plants. But not all capital is tangible. There are intangible assets, such as the knowledge and skills people build up through education and experience. These assets are otherwise known as human capital.
Economists dating back to the father of economics, Adam Smith, have conceptualized and sought to understand the impact of human capital. In his famous publication known as The Wealth of Nations, Smith wrote, “The acquisition of … talents during … education, study, or apprenticeship, costs a real expense, which is capital in [a] person. Those talents [are] part of his fortune [and] likewise that of society.” Smith here is making the case that education and experience constitutes capital as it requires costly investment and has clear economic value to a society.
So, how can we assess the value of human capital? Many economists have tried to understand the economic value of education. Work by eminent economists(1) has sought to produce estimates of wage and salary income as a function of years and quality of education, age, and experience. Such studies consistently show significant positive returns to years of education. In short, more education equals more income.
But that more education equals more income does not mean all education is of the same value or that “equal” education creates equal value. Rather, the formal education system is but one institution that develops the mind of the individual. This was made clear over 50 years ago in James Coleman’s landmark Equality of Educational Opportunity study, which was commissioned as part of 1964 Civil Rights Act. The Coleman study showed wide disparities in test scores along racial lines, which was of no surprise at the time. What was surprising was Coleman’s conclusion as to the cause. As stated in the report, “One implication stands out above all: That schools bring little influence to bear on a child’s achievement that is independent of his background and general social context; and that this very lack of an independent effect means that the inequalities imposed on children by their home, neighborhood, and peer environment are carried along to become the inequalities with which they confront adult life at the end of school.” In other words, education matters, but so do many other factors, including a person’s support system, opportunities available outside the classroom, and the neighborhood they grow up in.
Deficit or Debt?
Coleman’s finding does not refute the idea that more education increases human capital, but it does suggest formal education alone cannot overcome prior built-up deficits in human capital. If you consider the racial education achievement gap as more a function of past human capital investment deficits than a function of current education production, you are faced with a startling thought – you can’t properly address the achievement gap without considering the accumulation past generations’ deficits. And the accumulation of past deficits is commonly referred to in economics as a debt. This existence of an education debt was conceptualized by Dr. Gloria Ladson-Billings in her American Education Research Association 2006 Presidential Address(2). Ladson-Billings’ contention is, if the existence of this education debt generates current human capital deficits, you cannot possibly fix the deficit without fixing the debt. At a minimum, Ladson-Billings’ contention is we must take a holistic approach to address the achievement gap.
NJ Labor Market Outcomes by Race/Ethnicity
Keeping this framework in mind, we can turn our attention to the economic data in New Jersey, what inequalities persist, and what policies the State has in place to tackle them.
First, let’s look at some of the recent data and trends by race and ethnicity related to the labor market and income. Clearly there are significant disparities in labor market outcomes by race. Employment rates as of 2018 were rising for white, black, and Hispanic New Jerseyans, yet employment rates for minorities continued to lag that of white people. Real incomes were rising across the board as the economic expansion continued to mature. Yet for black people, as of 2018, the level of real income remained below where it was prior to the recession. And large disparities in real income by race and ethnicity persisted.
As the following chart shows, as of 2018, sharp disparities in educational achievement persisted by race and ethnicity. Given the evidence that more educational attainment yields more income, these educational achievement disparities probably explain a significant portion of disparities in labor market outcomes.
However, there is good news. Educational achievement rates for minorities are rising. Since the end of the recession through 2018, the share of the population aged 25+ with a college degree or more is up significantly among all major racial and ethnic groups.
NJ Entrepreneurship by Race/Ethnicity
Studies show education level is positively correlated with entrepreneurship and entrepreneurial success(3). Thus, lower levels of education among racial and ethnic minorities may be a barrier to entrepreneurship(4). Certainly in New Jersey, disparities in labor market outcomes and educational attainment are reflected in business ownership data.
According to the most recent publicly available data, non-Hispanic white people owned approximately 69 percent of New Jersey businesses while accounting for approximately 54 percent of the working-age population. This contrasts with non-Hispanic black people, who owned approximately 7 percent of businesses but accounted for approximately 14 percent of the working-age population. Hence, the data indicates disparities in business ownership along racial lines.
The disparities are even larger once you consider the share of businesses with employees, as distinct from sole proprietorships. As of 2012, only 5 percent of black-owned businesses and 11 percent of Hispanic-owned businesses had employees. By contrast, 25 percent non-Hispanic white-owned businesses and 32 percent of Asian-owned businesses had employees. When you aggregate the data, for companies with employees: 77 percent are owned by non-Hispanic white people, 2 percent by black people, 15 percent by Asians, and 6 percent by Hispanics. For companies without employees: 67 percent are owned by non-Hispanic white people, 9 percent by black people, 9 percent by Asians, 14 percent by Hispanics.
The positive news on this front is the most recent data on firms with employees shows solid growth in black-, Hispanic-, and Asian-owned firms.
New Jersey’s Holistic Approach
In this piece, we’ve discussed the significance of human capital for economic value creation, presented views on the causes and significance of racial and ethnic achievement gaps, and provided evidence on how underinvestment in human capital is evident in economic data. To address the issue of an education or general human capital debt calls for a holistic approach.
Governor Murphy’s Economic Plan for a stronger, fairer New Jersey takes a holistic approach to addressing this challenge by making high quality education from Pre-K through college more affordable and taking on other barriers to success with criminal justice reform and direct investments in underserved communities. Governor Murphy’s recently-released talent-based economic development strategy – “Jobs NJ: Developing Talent to Grow Business in the Garden State” – builds on these efforts to expand opportunities for career-seekers to gain skills and for employers to fill their talent needs. The plan lays out a collaborative, whole-of-government approach to enhance equity in the Garden State by ensuring all career-seeking New Jerseyans have the education and training necessary to access high-quality employment and that businesses and employers offering high-quality employment can quickly and efficiently fill their talent needs.
Part of addressing the problem is also realizing how long it takes for investments in human capital to reap benefits, so although investments in human capital are incredibly important, they may not sufficiently help people currently active in the labor or entrepreneurial market. On this front, we must appreciate how human capital is linked to access to financial capital. The evidence shows access to financial capital is lower for minority owners. For instance, one study found minority-owned businesses often rely more on personal and family wealth than external debt or equity for business financing(5). Another study showed that among businesses with annual gross receipts of $500,000, 17 percent of minority-owned businesses received loans, compared to 23 percent for nonminority-owned businesses(6). And access itself is not the only issue. Studies have shown minority owners, even when they need funding, are less likely to seek loans from banks for fear of rejection(7).
There are multiple NJEDA administered programs that focus on the problems of minority access to financial capital. The recently-expanded Angel Investor Tax Credit includes a 5 percent credit for investments made in firms located in Opportunity Zones and minority- or women-owned firms, and the new NJ Accelerate program matches loan funding up to $250,000 for start-up businesses, with an additional 5 percent loan for minority- and women-owned business enterprises. Furthermore, the NJEDA recently released a request for information to inform the potential creation of a diversity seed fund that would focus on driving capital to Black- and Latinx-owned enterprises. These programs, together with Governor Murphy’s other investments in a more holistic approach to addressing the human capital debt, should help move us toward a stronger, fairer New Jersey.
For more information on the Economist’s Corner, or to view the archive of Economist’s Corner postings, please visit www.njeda.com/economistcorner.
1 Jacob Mincer, Gary Becker, and James Heckman, to name a few
2 Ladson-Billings, G. (2006). From the achievement gap to the education debt: Understanding achievement in US schools. Educational researcher, 35(7), 3-12.
3 Fairlie, Robert, and Alicia Robb. 2010. “Disparities in Capital Access between Minority and Non-Minority-Owned Businesses: The Troubling Reality of Capital Limitations Faced by MBEs.” Minority Business Development Agency, U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, DC.
4. Barr, M. S. (2015). Minority and women entrepreneurs: Building capital, networks, and skills. Hamilton
Project Discussion Paper 2015-03. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
5 Robb, Alicia. 2013. “Access to Capital among Young Firms, Minority-Owned Firms, Women-Owned Firms, and High-Tech Firms.” Office of Advocacy, U.S. Small Business Administration, Washington, DC.
6 Fairlie and Robb, 2010.
7 Bates, Timothy, and Alicia Robb. 2013. “Small-Business Viability in America’s Urban Minority Communities.” Urban Studies. http://usj.sagepub.com/content/51/13/2844.full.pdf+html.
February 1, 2023
NJEDA Opens Applications for 2023 Historic Property Reinvestment Program
TRENTON, N.J (February 1, 2023) – Applications for the 2023 round of funding for the New Jersey Historic Property Reinvestment Program (HPRP) are now open...
February 1, 2023
NOTICE OF NJEDA BOARD MEETING - 02/08/2023
The New Jersey Economic Development Authority's next public Board Meeting will be held in person and via teleconference on Wednesday, February 8, 2023, at 10:00 am.
January 25, 2023
NJEDA to Host a Webinar on Phase 2 of the NJ Zero-Emission Incentive Program
TRENTON, N.J. (January 25, 2023) - The New Jersey Economic Development Authority (NJEDA) will host a webinar to provide small business owners...